Gas or electric
A gas unit has its burner under the tank and a chimney up the middle that lets exhaust and heat escape. An electric unit has heating elements inside the tank.
Installing a Bradford White gas tank to code, priced as a range.
Installation prices are a range, and repair and service visits are plus parts. The technician confirms the final number before any work starts.
A tank stores hot water for later. A tankless heats it as you use it. Here is what changes for your home.
New tankless installation: $5,200 to $6,300
A softener is priced separately.
General guidance: ENERGY STAR gas tankless benefits.
Gas and electric tanks work almost the same way. The difference is how they heat.
A gas unit has its burner under the tank and a chimney up the middle that lets exhaust and heat escape. An electric unit has heating elements inside the tank.
Tanks are generally tested to hold at least 300 psi. Most have a glass liner to stop the storage area rusting.
Insulation keeps the heat in. In most cases the insulation gets thicker as the price of the tank goes up.
A drain valve lets you empty the tank, and a pressure relief valve stops it from exploding.
Heaters rust from the inside out. A sacrificial anode rod decays first, protecting the parts that matter.
There's no pump. House pressure pushes cold water in, which sinks to the bottom because it's denser. Hot water builds up at the top, where the outlet is.
The thermostat holds the water at a set temperature. Heaters can reach 180°F, but normal operating temperatures are 120 to 140°F. We set every new heater to 120°F.
City water pressure is generally 50 to 100 psi. When you open a faucet, cold water flows in from the city line and settles at the bottom. As the temperature drops, the thermostat turns the burner or elements on.
Sizing a tank
40 gallons for 1 to 2 bathrooms, 50 gallons for 2 to 3, and 75 gallons for 3 to 4.
Why Brandon chooses Bradford White
Brandon at Quick Water Heater · 0:24–0:55
Brandon explains why he chooses Bradford White, from his experience with their parts and support.
Watch on YouTubeFrom Brandon's cost breakdown for replacing a 40 gallon gas heater (2022). Prices have moved since, but the parts list hasn't.
A fan on top forces exhaust up the vent and mixes in cooler air, so the vent can be PVC and run in any direction. Common in condos built after 2000 where a vertical vent isn't possible.
They cost roughly $1,300 to $1,600 before installation, two to three times a standard heater. They're more efficient, but the onboard computer and fan make them less reliable in later years.
Strapped, insulated and vented, the way every tank we put in should look.

Optional cover for parts and labor. See what it adds to your installation in dollars.