Skip to content

Water heater replacement

Out with the old tank, hot water by the afternoon.

Same day replacement from San Diego's most reviewed water heater company. Transparent pricing, contractor grade equipment, and 5,000+ installations across San Diego County.

  • 100% transparent pricing
  • Same day replacement available
  • Tank and tankless options with up to a 15 year warranty

Selling your home?Tell us your plans

4.9 from 1,300+ Google and Yelp reviews

A Quick Water Heater technician pointing to a new Bradford White water heater

When to replace your water heater

Not every problem calls for a new heater. Sometimes a thermocouple or a T&P valve is all you need. But in these cases, a replacement makes more sense than putting money into an aging system.

  • Leaking from the base

    Water pooling under the tank means the anode rod has decayed and the tank has corroded. The most common reason we replace heaters, and almost never a repair.

  • Age of the heater

    Most tanks last 8 to 12 years. Past that range, a planned replacement avoids the emergency call when it finally fails.

  • Rust colored hot water

    Usually a spent anode rod and corroding tank walls. A new anode can help if caught early. If it persists, it's time.

  • Frequent repairs

    More than one repair call in a year on a heater over 8 years old adds up fast. A new heater comes with a fresh warranty.

  • Not enough hot water

    Sediment at the bottom cuts capacity. Annual flushing helps, but neglected tanks may be past what a flush can fix.

  • Rising energy bills

    Older tanks run at about 62% efficiency. Modern units, especially tankless at about 95%, cost less every month.

Tank or tankless?

Both have real advantages. It comes down to how much hot water you use, your budget, and whether you'll add the water softener a tankless needs in San Diego.

TankTankless
Energy efficiencyAbout 62%About 95%
Typical warranty6 years15 years on the heat exchanger
Hot water supplyLimited by tank size (40 to 75 gal)Unlimited, on demand
Lifespan8 to 12 years15 to 20 years
SpaceFloor space for the tankWall mounted and compact
Upfront costLowerHigher, with lower running costs
MaintenanceFlush and inspect the anode as the manual requiresA yearly flush, unless you have water treatment
Water treatmentOptionalA softener, or a yearly flush

Why San Diego's hard water changes the equation

Hard water leaves mineral scale in a heat exchanger. The scale lowers performance and can damage the unit. Water treatment reduces that buildup.

A tankless needs a yearly flush. With a softener or scale prevention system, there's no need to flush it.

Brandon explains

Why Brandon chooses Bradford White

Brandon at Quick Water Heater · 0:24–0:55

Brandon explains why he chooses Bradford White, from his experience with their parts and support.

Watch on YouTube

What we recommend

Contractor grade equipment, bought through professional supply houses, with a direct line to support when something goes wrong.

  • Top pick, tank

    Bradford White

    Our go to for tank replacements. American made, quality materials and excellent manufacturer support. Our supplier, Ferguson, stocks every part for same day availability. Not sold at big box stores.

  • Top pick, tankless

    Navien

    Stainless steel heat exchangers, built to be serviced, and many models with integrated recirculation, so every faucet gets hot water straight away without wasting water.

  • Brands we avoid

    We don't install big box store heaters. The retail warranty process is a nightmare: homeowners have told us about 8 hours or more on the phone trying to get warranty service.

The Ridiculous Warranty

Optional cover for parts and labor. See what it adds to your installation in dollars.

Warranty details

How a replacement works

Streamlined over thousands of installs to be as fast and painless as possible.

  1. 1

    On site estimate

    A $395 visit. We assess your setup and hot water needs, and price it out by equipment, materials and labor. No hidden fees.

  2. 2

    Choose the equipment

    We recommend the right unit for your household and budget. Bradford White tanks and Navien tankless ride on our trucks for same day swaps when possible.

  3. 3

    Professional installation

    Removal of the old unit, the new heater, an expansion tank (required in California), venting, gas or electrical, seismic straps and all plumbing. Permit by you, or by us for an extra fee.

  4. 4

    Testing and walkthrough

    We test everything, set the temperature to 120°F, and show you the shutoff valve, the yearly T&P check and when to inspect the anode rod.

Make your new heater last

Tank water heaters

  • Flush the tank, check the anode rod and test the relief valve on the schedule in your heater's manual.
  • Have a qualified technician assess a blocked drain valve and select a model compatible replacement if one is needed.

Tankless water heaters

  • Hard water leaves mineral scale in a heat exchanger. The scale lowers performance and can damage the unit. Water treatment reduces that buildup.
  • Without water treatment, plan on a yearly flush. With a water treatment system, there's no need to flush a tankless.
  • Have a technician check an older unit with no service history before cleaning it.

Replacement questions

  • How do I know if I need a replacement?

    The clearest sign is a leak at the base of the tank, which means internal corrosion from a decayed anode rod. Other signs: a heater 8 to 12+ years old, rust colored hot water, less hot water and frequent repairs. An on site estimate anywhere in San Diego County is $395.

  • Should I replace my tank with tankless?

    A tankless costs 2 to 3 times as much up front, then saves $175 to $275 a year and lasts up to 10 years longer than a tank. A conversion needs new venting and electrical work. The existing gas line works 99% of the time.

  • How long does a replacement take?

    A tank to tank swap takes 2 to 4 hours. Tank to tankless takes 4 to 8 hours because of the gas line, venting and electrical work. If your heater fails in the morning, you can have hot water by the afternoon.

  • Which brands do you recommend?

    Bradford White for tanks (American made, contractor grade, same day parts locally) and Navien for tankless (stainless steel parts, built in recirculation on the A models, excellent reliability). We don't install big box store brands.

  • Do I need a permit?

    Yes. San Diego requires a permit for water heater replacements, and California requires an expansion tank with every new install. You can pull your own permit, or we handle it for an additional fee.

  • What's included?

    Removal and disposal of the old unit, the new water heater, an expansion tank, water and gas connections, seismic straps, testing and a maintenance walkthrough. You get the full price before any work starts.

Ready for a new water heater? Get the price before any work starts.